I remember that it happened on Saturday March 28th, 2009


Ambohijatovo democracy square was already full at 10.00am
The rally of Saturday March 28th was scheduled as a sort of

Please, be carefull“, this is what my friends and relatives told me when they knew that I would go to Ambohijatovo democracy square on Saturday March 28th to attend the rally that the “legalists” in Madagascar have made since Saturday March 21st.

vo-tonga-ihany

I understood that they were afraid of eventual clashes between the ralliers and the TGV supporters. For five days (since Monday March 23rd), there have been regular confrontings between TGV supporters and ralliers in Analakely May 13th square. The police always puts an end to such confrontings by intervening (most of the time, after one hour of fight) with tear-gas, sky-shooting and arrests. The legalists, since Saturday March 21st, have not planned to do a rally on Analakely May 13th square. According to the leaders of the anti-coup d’état movement, most of their ralliers have to pass by this place to go home. “May 13th square is a public place. Why should  not we go or pass by there?” ask Raharinaivo Andrianatoandro, MP for the jurisdiction of Ambohidratrimo and spokesman of TIM (political party created by Marc Ravalomanana).

scooter-015

Alain Ramaroson

Alain Ramaroson, leader of the FDC (Democratic Forces for Change) and close collaborator of Andry Rajoelina, clearly stated on Friday March 27th in a interview to a local TV that he and his “boay kely” (hooligans) would never allow the ralliers to have meetings at Analakely May 13th square. He added: “this place is sacred … it was not easy for us “to get” this place … we won’t let these bastards to profane it

estimate about the number of people: 15,000 to 20,000
estimate about the number of people: 15,000 to 20,000

Political prisoners

The 28 political prisoners who have been freed by a presidential pardon granted by Andry Rajoelina on Saturday March 21st (during his ceremony of official installation in Mahamasina stadium), have also expressed their hostility towards this new opposition movement. They said that they (the political prisoners) don’t need the help of the militaries to “eliminate” this movement.

Besides, these 28 former political prisoners made a press conference at the “Motel d’Antananarivo” on Monday March 30th in which Pety Rakotoniaina (former mayor of Fianarantsoa) declared: “we consider the movement of Ravalomanana supporters in Ambohijatovo as a insult towards the “popular fight”. We have to put an end to that fight. In this regard, we call all Antananarivo people to come to Ambohijatovo democracy square on Tuesday March 31st to support us. We have already filed our application to obtain a public meeting authorization before the CUA (Mayor’s office – Antananarivo)”.

“What you do in Ambohijatovo is a subversive action which aims to make a show of crisis, in order to facilitate the intervention of SADC. We can not accept that. Through keeping such attitude, you insult the people and its leaders. Now, I warn you … do not come back anymore in Ambohijatovo”, Emmanuel Razafindrazaka, former general inspector of police (locally known as General Bôlô) said during this press conference.

scooter-016

Association of the defenders of the transition regime

It seems that the transitional administration of Andry Rajoelina starts to be seriously afraid of this anti-coup d’état movement. The setting-up of the association of the defenders of the transition regime, which gathers the students from Ankatso university (led by a famous striker: Mamy Jo), clubs of young people from Antananarivo ghettos, and reservists, is among the expression of such fear. This association has clearly expressed his readiness to defend by “any means” the transition regime.

This new association made a press conference on Friday March 27th at “Restaurant Mon Goûter” to present its members.

scooter-019

The rally

Surely, the number of ralliers has achieved its climax on Saturday March 28th: Ambohijatovo democracy square was fully crowded! According to estimates, there were around 15,000 to 20,000 people who joined the rally.
oay

Most of the famous MPs from TIM and other political parties were on stage

Ravonison Ambroise: “if you are a TGV, then we are a jet!”

Alain Andriamiseza (leader of MCDM: Christian Democrat Movement of Madagascar): “We started in Ambohijatovo. We will pass by May 13th square. And we will arrive in Ambotsirohitra. In order to achieve that, we have to act cautiously to avoid breakages”

Jean Louis Rakotoamboa, national president of TEZA (political party close to Marc Ravalomanana): “we have lived during 02 months with terrorism and dictatorship. We will block during 15 days the “administrative machine” to destroy this transition.” He also warned the French banks in Madagascar against fundings granted to the HAT (High Authority of Transition) through treasury bills.

Célestin Randrianarivony, national coordinator of legalist civil servants: “It starts! We will not stop anymore! We will not negotiate anymore despite the call of the primeminister Monja Roindefo.”

Constant Raveloson, General Secretary of MFM: “Legalist militaries, take all necessary measures and stand up against this coup d’état of Andry Rajoelina! This is a shame for militaries!”

kay

reo-daholy

reo-wa

scooter-045

General strike

The leaders of the movement have declared that because the ultimatum that they gave to Andry Rajoelina to step down on Saturday March 21st, has expired and that they got no satisfactory answer from this latter, then, the whole nation (…) will go on strike starting from Monday March 30th.

scooter-011

They said that all public offices would be closed starting from Monday in order to show to the current administration that all Malagasy civil servants are against Andry Rajoelina’s coup d’état, some representatives from civil servants said. With a complete paralysis of the “administrative machine”, the regime of transition of Andry Rajoelina would not stand even 15 days, they added.

aoka-wa

“As soon as all public infrastructures are paralyzed … it is unavoidable, this fake regime will collapse by itself …” They added.

blou

It is clear then that starting from Monday, there will be no open public offices. Nevertheless, till now (Monday till Wednesday), some ministerial departments still remain open for the public and there are civil servants who still work. According to one of them (who wanted to remain anonymous), those who have publicly expressed their will to go on strike, have been threatened.

scooter-022

Colleges and Schools are also invited to take part into the general strike. Concerning private companies, they said that they do not want to force the employers as well as private employees to join their movement. “Everybody is free to join us or not … we do not want to bring more casualties to Malagasy private companies … we rely on the decision of each employer” Raveloson Constant (MP from MFM political party) said.

scooter-031

There were also some representatives from the other regions. They stated that there are several opposition movements throughout the other regions which are now raising up. “This is not only the fight of Antananarivo! This is the resistance of a whole nation!” One of them said.

scooter-033

scooter-036

a representative from Ankatso university
a representative from Ankatso university

scooter-122

Raveloson Constant, MP from MFM political party
Raveloson Constant, MP from MFM political party

scooter-125

the so-called "satro-bory"
the so-called "satro-bory"
The MP of Ambohidratrimo (TIM): Raharinaivo
The MP of Ambohidratrimo (TIM): Raharinaivo

Some people (I do not really know who …) have attempted to disturb the rally by sprinkling the ralliers with acid liquid. They did not succeed because they have been caught red-handed before doing anything.

The organisers of the rally showed to the public the bottle full of acid liquid
The organisers of the rally showed to the public the bottle full of acid liquid
they wanted to sprinkle people with it
they wanted to sprinkle people with it

There were also some representaives from TIKO Group’s employees (the group of companies which belongs to Marc Ravalomanana, who denounced the fact that their companies were facing a lot of problems and impediments from the militaries and from the HAT.

seza

TIKO companies throughout Madagascar can not deliver by themselves their products anymore because their goods are always seized by militaries on their way. Consequently, TIKO companies only sell to companies which have the necessary means to pick up the goods. As a result, most of shops throughout Madagascar lack TIKO products (milk, butter, yoghourt, cheese, ice ceam, juice, …). This has created huge losses to the TIKO Group and obliged it to suspend their activities till the end of the crisis (decision made by the general manager of  TIKO Group on Monday April 06th). Since Benja Razafimahaleo has taken over the ministry of finance, he has always harassed TIKO Group about outstanding taxes and customes duties.

alefa

_________________________________________________________________

Now, We will all go to May 13th square!

oooeee

The MP Constant Raveloson declared at the end of the meeting: “Now is the time to show to Andry Rajoelina, to the whole nation and to the world, our real strength, let us show to them that we are not afraid to express our opposition to this coup d’état. The May 13th square belongs to any citizen, it is our right to go there and to carry on our rally there!”. Ralliers could not hide their massive happiness when they heard that. Now, we will all go to May 13th square!

Actually, their plan was to go to May 13th square to listen to a telephonic message from Marc Ravalomanana. Such message incited Malagasy people to fight against a new form of colonization in force in Madagascar.

constant1

It has been decided that MPs will lead the march to May 13th square. All the ralliers will follow them in a kind of compact group. Before that the MPs could leave Ambohijatovo democracy square, some ralliers (all young) were already waiting outside the square in Andohan’Analakely.

rank

After I took this picture, there was a guy who tried to provoke me. He wanted to know why did I take these pictures. Through his eyes, I could see that this guy was under the effect of some drugs. Obviously, he wanted to fight. I told him that I was a blogger (this kind of guy does not even know what an Email is …) and that it was my right to be there to take as much pictures as I want. The guy started to shout: “I don’t care! Don’t take pictures! Go!”. Then he tried to take my camera … I have been obliged to protect myself. We have fighted for 02 minutes and he ran away. Latter, I discovered that this guy has laso tried to bother some journalists who were there.

Led by the MPs, the ralliers started to head to Analakely May 13th square. People were asked to stay calm to avoid clashes. Security forces and TGV supporters were waiting near the military camp RM1. TGV supporters had bars and swords. Strange thing: security forces did nothing to disperse TGV supporters. We clearly had the feeling that they were supporting one another …

rm1

ndao-aza

vahoaka

scooter-137

scooter-1381

scooter-139

scooter-140

scooter-141

scooter-142

scooter-143

scooter-144

scooter-145

scooter-1461

When the crowd came near “Glacier”, militaries launched the first tear-gas (01.15pm Madagascar time), the ralliers did not stop moving forward. Militaries threw deafening grenades and sky-shooted to threaten people, but ralliers did not care much, they kept on moving forward.

Suddenly, a military shooted with a real bullet and one rallier (André Razanadrakoto) was hit on his right lap. Seeing that, most of the ralliers started to move back.

Then Yves Aimé Rakotoarisoa, MP for the jurisdiction of Tolagnaro (TIM) was hit on his face by a tear-gas. He collapsed. Ralliers got panicked and all ran away. TGV supporters ran after them and stoned them.

When the ralliers, while moving back to Andohan’Anakely, were near the military camp of RM1, the militaries from this camp went out and shooted with real bullets. People all scattered away and tried to run away from the fire of RM1’s militaries, the tear-gas of other security forces and the stones of TGV supporters.

Most of the ralliers re-gathered in Ambohijatovo. Unexpected action from security forces, they kept on running after the ralliers, forcing these latters to escape till Ambatonakanga and Ambanidia.

Then, there were CAPSAT soldiers on SUVs who chased the ralliers till the top of Ambatonakanga (near the headquarters of  Sea Force) and till the Ambanidia tunnel.  They used machine guns.

Because security forces started to "chase" people, ralliers went up to Ambatonakanga
Because security forces started to "chase" people, ralliers went up to Ambatonakanga

That was really schocking for everybody. Initially, the security forces were scheduled to avoid the clashes between legalists and TGV supporters. Why did they chase people outside the perimeter of  May 13th square?

Ralliers were terrified with the strength of the repression from security forces
Ralliers were terrified with the strength of the repression from security forces
Security forces did not only "clean" May 13th square, but also "secured" the surrounding districts
Security forces did not only "clean" May 13th square, but also "secured" the surrounding districts
Ralliers did not expect such reaction / repression from security forces
Ralliers did not expect such reaction / repression from security forces
The first ambulance
The first ambulance
Ralliers still do not understand why security forces shooted at them
Ralliers still do not understand why security forces shooted at them
Moreover, many of them have eye-witnessed some ralliers who were killed by security forces near the RM1 camp
Moreover, many of them have eye-witnessed some ralliers who were killed by security forces near the RM1 camp
Ralliers still do not understand why did not security forces disperse also the TGV supporters who were waiting at May 13th square
Ralliers still do not understand why did not security forces disperse also the TGV supporters who were waiting at May 13th square
A woman who has been severely wounded by security forces, she has been picked up by red cross ambulance
A woman who has been severely wounded by security forces, she has been picked up by red cross ambulance
Ralliers ran away when security forces charge at them ...
Ralliers ran away when security forces charge at them ...
... and ralliers came back to the "battle field" (Andohan'Analakely and Ambohijatovo) to challenge security forces
... and ralliers came back to the "battle field" (Andohan'Analakely and Ambohijatovo) to challenge security forces
This kind of "game" lasted for 01 hour and half
This kind of "game" lasted for 01 hour and half
a TGV supporter caught and beaten by ralliers
a TGV supporter caught and beaten by ralliers
Ralliers still do not understand why the HAT has forbidden the access of May 13th square
Ralliers still do not understand why the HAT has forbidden the access of May 13th square
The minister of homeland security stated on Monday March 30th that security forces did not use any "real bullet". Here is the proof that he lied
The minister of homeland security stated on Monday March 30th that security forces did not use any "real bullet". Here is the proof that he lied

scooter-167

case bullets ...
case bullets ...

most of the ambulances headed to HJRA hospital (Hospital Joseph Ravoangy Andrianavalona)

most of the ambulances headed to HJRA hospital (Hospital Joseph Ravoangy Andrianavalona)

At HJRA hospital

At 06.00pm (Madagascar time), Stéphane (a blogger) and I arrived  to HJRA hospital. We have decide to go there to have some concrete ideas about the real “casualties” of this event. This was the nearest hospital where we could go (it is located in Andrefan’Ambohijanahary). We really wanted to know what was happening there because we were informed by some ralliers that most of the wounded people were brought to HJRA hospital.

Once we arrived there, we were amazed to see the number of people who waited around the premises of the hospital. There were people who came there because their relatives or friends have disappeared. Some went there to pick up their relatives. But most of them were there because they felt concerned about what was happening to their co-ralliers.

Most of the wounded people have already been picked up by their relatives. The doctor-in-chief told to us that there were 43 people injured. He also said that as far as HJRA hospital is concerned, they did not record any death.

intensive care unit of HJRA hospital
intensive care unit of HJRA hospital

scooter-164

scooter-165

This woman has been shot when she wanted to take a bus in Ambohijatovo, she planned to attend a private course
This woman has been shot when she wanted to take a bus in Ambohijatovo, she planned to attend a private course
This 15 years old girl has been shot when she was in Paraky
This 15 years old girl has been shot when she was in Paraky
Paraky is located between Ankadimbahoaka and Andrefan'Ambohijanahary
Paraky is located between Ankadimbahoaka and Andrefan'Ambohijanahary
This man was in Anosy when he got shot
This man was in Anosy when he got shot

I met the MP Raharinaivo Andrianatoandro (spokesman of TIM) who told me that the MP for the jurisdiction of 02nd borough of Antananarivo, William Rakotomahefanoro (principal of Lycée Faravohitra (the former Lycée Jules Ferry)) has disappeared during the clash and nobody, including his own family, knows where he is. He is unreachable on his mobile phone.

After some investigations, we have found out that he has not been arrested or killed by security forces or by TGV supporters. Now, he hides himself from authorities because he has been aware just after the clash of March 28th, that the HAT was planning to arrest him. The reason may be the following:

Thursday March 26th, the HAT minister of education, Jules Razafimanjato, made a unexpected visit to Lycée Faravohitra. He was immediately booed by students. The day after, the students from Lycée Faravohitra came massively to the rally at Ambohijatovo Democracy Park.

The MP also said that they (the legalists movement) have never been formally or informally informed or notified by the authorities that they can not pass by or make a rally at May 13th square.

He finally declared that he has heard from some eye-witnesses that there were ralliers who have been killed, but militaries from RM1 has taken their bodies to their camp. They (the militaries) even said to some people: “ask your dad (Marc Ravalomanana) to go here to take them!”. Such assertion has not been confirmed yet.

Raharinaivo Andrianatoandro, MP for the jurisdiction of Amboditsiry and spokesman of TIM
Raharinaivo Andrianatoandro, MP for the jurisdiction of Amboditsiry and spokesman of TIM

7 thoughts on “I remember that it happened on Saturday March 28th, 2009

  1. i wonder if this site is really a city observer? or just a blog to improve the english of the narrator or rather the story teller?

    1. Ravalomanana supporters argued that Andry Rajoelina and Monja Roindefo paid their followers and the “CAPSAT mutineers” to fulfil their ambition.
    Isn’t Marc Ravalomanana the richest man on the island, why didn’t he offer a higher bid?
    If Andry and Roindefo gave the CAPSAT 700 millions of Malagasy francs (about 70.000 euros), why didn’t Ravalomanana and his supporters offer a higher bid of 1 billion of Malagasy francs (about 100.000 euros), which is pocket money for a man like Ravalomanana? Belive it or not, the TIKO group daily turnover is more than 1 billion!

    If the reason of the mutiny was just a “good amount” of money, damn, solve the problem with just a “bigger amount” of money and basta !
    If the reason of the protests was just the number of people on 13 may place, why didn’t Ravalomanana paid those protesters a higher amount of money in exchange for not coming in 13 may square?
    As far as I know , Monja Roindefo or Andry Rajoelina is not as rich as “legalists”, are they ?

    Do you want to know what Andry followers chanted? TSY VOAVIDY VOLA!!!! (translation: you can’t buy us ! we are out of price! Our support for Andry is priceless!)

    In a nutshell, money has nothing to do with the CAPSAT mutiny or the protest on 13 may square.

    2. If the army, the gendarme and the police with thousand of protesters ASKED a president to resign and when the president resign but give the power to a military directorate and when this later didn’t want the power but give it to the leader of the opposition, the international community called that a coup.
    If now the same army, the gendarme and the police with thousand of protesters KILLED a president and give it the power to the leader of the opposition, what the international community would call this situation?
    Is the role played by the army the problem here?
    If protesters( without the backing of the army) asked a president to resign and when the president resign but give the power to a military directorate and when this later didn’t want the power but give it to the leader of the opposition, what the international community would call this another situation?

    3. By the international community standard, any means to ask or force a president to resign is a coup. Even democratic means such as demonstration are not acceptable.
    The president can violate the constitution but opposition must follow the constitution to the letter.
    The constitution is written for the opposition, not for the president!
    Do you really think it’s in the constitution that the president can shoot on and kill empty-handed protesters when they try to enter a presidential palace? Do you think it’s in the constitution that the president can shut a private station if it criticizes his regime? Do you think it’s in the constitution that the president can order the army to ban protesters the access to the 13 may square?
    The president can use undemocratic and unconstitutional means to stay in power whereas protesters and the opposition must use democratic and constitutional means to get power!!!
    Really strange!
    By the international community standard, a president who uses undemocratic and unconstitutional means to stay in power is a dictator. BUT the international community doesn’t allow you to force a dictator out of power by unconstitutional and undemocratic means.
    Saddam Hussein was a dictator. Is the eviction of Saddam Hussein or is the invasion of Iraq a democratic and constitutional means?
    Does the international community really think, it is possible to force a dictator out of power by democratic and constitutional means? Tell us in Madagascar how to do that?

  2. Thqnk you for all you did to bring us the truth! I hope many will send your blog to others, even internationally.

  3. I’m sorry I don’t laugh at the victims but it is very much ironical the course of politics in Mada! If I would post in a blog all the pics of victims of Feb 07 killed by Ra8 or his security guards, it would look uglier and worse than these photos to be sincere.

    let it be clear>> It was a Coup d’Etat according to the definition of “Coup d’État” (see Wikipedia) . HOWEVER, given the enormous scale of natural resources dilapidation by the last incumbent, it might as well be called “a necessary Coup d’Etat” (un mal nécessaire). Anything else beyond that cannot be called unconstitutional since it has not been mandated by the Constitution (the whole transitional government thing). Well, killing of protesters are also unconstitutional but no one called Ra8 unconstitutional as because maybe respect of human rights are part of the Preamble and not part of the Art. & Sect. of the Constitution. (I’m really being ironical)

    Then, the “legalists” would hassle me with : why then the Americans DID wait till the end of Bush’s mandate in order to elect their choice even though Bush was very much endangering the lives & interests of Americans abroad through his foreign policies??

    The answer is simple: Bush has never killed his fellow Americans unlike Ra8 even though his anti-presidential protestors YES, climbed/tried to climb the gate of White house , Bush has not been unconstitutional towards his own country unlike the strings of laws broken by the previous incumbent.

    No, he’s not just exercising his English. He has been trained in an english-speaking country. But definitely, this type of blogs reflects that there’s a chasm among the community of Mlagasy trained abroad in english-speaking countries. There are those who became traitors to their own country (I’m wondering why they did not use TIM (I Love Mcar) anymore but “legalists” instead) (some scholars & bursars) & those who studied in those countries to aspire that their country would be like them one day.

  4. Just a litttle correction Anonymous> Bush was supposed by many not to havy killed his fellow Americans back then (that’s why he was still kept in power) but imagine that with the amount of documentaries that abound now about 9/11, do u still think Americans were not going to ask for justice???? Anyway, interesting analysis.

  5. keep on disinforming the world andrydago, you are past master at it!!!
    when you are at it, why don’t tell the world that Rajoelina killed Michael Jackson?
    You better serve your country if you use your knowledge to defend the right person not the criminal?

    for the record, the term “brouillage” doesn’t exist in the malagasy broadcasting landscape till Ravalomanana came in power!!!! hat down to ya, mister president.
    and andrydago is still claiming there was democracy during ravalomanan’s reign, shame on you andrydago!!!!shame on you!
    ramandriaka@yahoo.fr

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s